Community property is a legal concept that governs the division of acquired marital assets. It is different from equitable distribution laws in several ways. In community property states, all property acquired during marriage is presumed by law to be owned equally by both spouses, irrespective of whose name it bears.
The concept of community property does not apply in British Columbia; instead, the province follows the equalization of net family property. This means that on separation, equal shares in all divisible assets accumulated during the marriage (with some exclusions) will be made between the partners regardless of their holding legal title.
This blog post will discuss community property laws with an emphasis on clarity.
What is Community Property in a Divorce?
Community property laws may be restricted to some parts of the Western and Southwestern United States; however, this is not the case for British Columbia.
Rather, the Province of British Columbia subscribes to the principle of equal distribution of net family property. This signifies that when spouses separate, there will be a sharing of the property acquired during the period of marriage, less exemptions, where it does not matter who the legal holder is.
Key Differences
While both community property law and equalization aim for a fair division of assets, there are some key differences:
- Presumption: Under the community property system, any asset acquired by either party during the marriage is considered jointly owned. However, BC spouses own separate property acquired during their time together unless there is proof it was meant to be communal ownership.
- Separate Property: Separate Property generally cannot be divided up in community-property states. In BC, however, this would depend on how much each spouse’s net worth comes to once all obligations and other factors are considered.
- Commingling: Nevertheless, commingling separate properties with common ones can be a factor in some jurisdictions; still, BC’s equalization approach towards asset allocation goes beyond that.
How Community Property is Divided in Divorce
In British Columbia, the division of marital property is according to the equalization of net family property principle, which means that on separation, the net value of divisible assets acquired during marriage (except for certain exceptions) will be shared equally between the spouses.
Factors Affecting Property Division
There may be several factors that influence the division of marital property:
Duration of Marriage: Longer marriages tend to favor a more equal distribution.
Contributions: The contributions made by both parties towards acquiring and preserving the property.
Financial Situation: It is crucial to consider each spouse’s economic needs and circumstances.
Domestic Violence: The court may consider this if one of the spouses has been abused in their family in dividing property.
What Happens to Property Owned Before Marriage in BC
The property obtained by any spouse before marriage usually falls under separate property. It is not subject to division upon separation or divorce. Nonetheless, suppose any separate property intermingles with a marital one, like when separate funds are applied to buying a family home. In that case, it may change its character, and some parts might be subject to division.
Property Acquired After Separation but Before Divorce in BC
Generally, property acquired by either spouse after separation but before divorce is deemed separate. However, when marital funds are used in purchasing such a property or if it was bought with the other partner’s financial support, it may not be protected.
Key Differences Between Community Property and Separate Property
While British Columbia does not follow a strict community property system, understanding the key differences between community property and separate property can be helpful in navigating property division during separation or divorce.
Community Property
Presumption of Equal Ownership: In states with community property laws, all property acquired during the marriage is presumed to be jointly owned by both spouses.
Limited Exceptions: Certain types of property, such as inheritances or gifts, may be considered separate property.
Commingling: If a separate property is commingled with community property, it may lose its separate character.
Separate Property
Individual Ownership: Property owned before the marriage is consummated, inherited, or gifted to one of the spouses is usually considered separate.
No Presumption of Equal Ownership: The person who brought this asset remains its sole proprietor.
Commingling: When a piece of separate property gets mixed up with the community properties, part of it can become liable for division.
Key Differences in British Columbia
While British Columbia does not follow a strict community property system, the equalization of net family property shares some similarities. Here are the key differences:
- Presumption of Equal Division: In British Columbia, the presumption is for an equal division of all divisible assets acquired during the marriage, regardless of who holds legal title.
- Broader Scope: Equalization encompasses a more comprehensive range of assets compared to community property.
- Individual Ownership: Spouses retain ownership of property acquired before the marriage or received as gifts or inheritances.
Spousal Liens on Marital Property in British Columbia
A spousal lien refers to the right that one of the spouses has over the house occupied by the couple within their marriage as a guarantee for payment in case of divorce. Hence, it must be a security interest so that in a future sale or distribution, some other party will be entitled to compensation for that particular issue.
When a Spousal Lien May Be Appropriate
A spousal lien may be considered in the following situations:
Protection of Financial Interests: If one spouse believes their financial interests are at risk due to the other spouse’s actions, such as selling or transferring property without their consent.
Pending Property Division: While the division of marital property is typically addressed through the equalization process, a spousal lien can provide additional security during the separation period.
Preventing Dissipation of Assets: If there is a concern that one spouse may attempt to sell or dispose of assets before the final property division, a spousal lien can help prevent this.
How to Establish a Spousal Lien
Generally, however, a spousal lien is obtained by one partner applying to the court to provide the lien. Such an application should clearly show what grounds are relied upon for claiming such a lien and which properties are affected. For that reason, it may be necessary to produce supplementary evidence such as income statements or deeds that are sufficient proof of transfer of ownership.
Solutions Family Law: Your Partner in Navigating Marital Property Division
When facing the complexities of marital property division in British Columbia, having a trusted legal partner by your side is crucial. Solutions Family Law’s highly experienced family law lawyers possess the expertise and dedication to guide you through this process, ensuring your rights and interests are protected.
To analyze your situation, our team will meticulously review it and establish your assets and liabilities. After that, we will negotiate for a fair distribution among the parties of the marital property. We understand the emotional and financial implications of dividing property. We are committed to offering caring and effective legal services in this regard.
FAQs
-
1- Who gets the house in a divorce in Canada?
In Canada, the equalization of the net family properties process determines who gets the house in a divorce. Among other things, several factors are taken into account, such as
- contributions towards ownership,
- length of marriage,
- children present,
- financial conditions prevailed at that time, and previous debts had accumulated.
The court may order the sale but can also award one spouse or allow joint ownership.
-
2- What is a wife entitled to in a divorce in Canada?
In Canada, both spouses have equal rights in a divorce, regardless of gender. Entitlements depend on factors like marriage length, financial contributions, standard of living, needs, and whether there are children. Key entitlements include:
Property Division: Equal division of marital property.
Spousal Support: Potential for spousal support.
Child Support: Obligation for the non-custodial parent.
Custody and Access: Arrangements for children’s care and visitation.
-
3- How long after separation can you claim assets BC?
Two years after separation is generally the limitation period within which claims for assets must be commenced. Such a provision applies if you were legally married or just living with each other as common-law spouses.
